Newfoundland essay help please???!!! *desperate at this point *?

Ok so we had a debate in cl and in the end we decided that newfoundand will join the other countries. I have to write it in a 1st person from either Sir Ambrose Shea (1815-1905), n.d. or Sir Frederick Terrington Carter. Which one should i choose and why? I have to write a essay about why or why not we should join confederation please help!!!!